• FREE RESOURCES
        • Accounts Payable
          Finally! The trick to securing greater T&E compliance
          Benefits
          Rooting out folks who don’t belong on your health plan: A 6-point dependent audit checklist
          IT
          3 costly misconceptions about biz email compromise
          Credit and Collections
          Collecting via email: 4 must-make moves in your subject line
          Accounts Payable
          5 Tough-to-spot signs that an invoice is fake
  • PREMIUM CONTENT
        • Staff management
          120 Proven Communications Tips for Today’s CFO
        • Payroll
          Handling Nonexempt Employee Pay: Stay Compliant and Avoid DOL Audits
          Accounts Payable
          T&E Best Practices: Complete Guide to Ensure Compliance
          Payroll
          Payroll Best Practices: 4 Ways to Save Time and Money
        • Staff management
          Email Best Practices: A 6-Question Quiz
          Staff management
          Innovative Communications Strategies: An Email Case Study
          Staff management
          A 5-part Framework for Successful Workplace Communications
        • SEE MORE
          PREMIUM RESOURCES
  • CORONAVIRUS RESOURCES
  • LOGIN
  • SIGN UP FREE

CFO Daily News

  • FREE RESOURCES
        • Accounts Payable
          Finally! The trick to securing greater T&E compliance
          Benefits
          Rooting out folks who don’t belong on your health plan: A 6-point dependent audit checklist
          IT
          3 costly misconceptions about biz email compromise
          Credit and Collections
          Collecting via email: 4 must-make moves in your subject line
          Accounts Payable
          5 Tough-to-spot signs that an invoice is fake
  • PREMIUM CONTENT
        • Staff management
          120 Proven Communications Tips for Today’s CFO
        • Payroll
          Handling Nonexempt Employee Pay: Stay Compliant and Avoid DOL Audits
          Accounts Payable
          T&E Best Practices: Complete Guide to Ensure Compliance
          Payroll
          Payroll Best Practices: 4 Ways to Save Time and Money
        • Staff management
          Email Best Practices: A 6-Question Quiz
          Staff management
          Innovative Communications Strategies: An Email Case Study
          Staff management
          A 5-part Framework for Successful Workplace Communications
        • SEE MORE
          PREMIUM RESOURCES
  • CORONAVIRUS RESOURCES
  • Accounts Payable
  • Credit and Collections
  • Payroll
  • Accounting
  • Benefits
  • Finance Technology
  • More
    • Employment Law
    • Strategy
    • Policy and Culture
    • Fraud
    • Payments and Transactions
    • Budgeting and Forecasting
    • Banking
    • Staff Management
    • Cost Control
    • Supply Chain
    • IT

Can overtime be an ‘essential job function’ under federal law?

Jared Bilski
by Jared Bilski
April 28, 2016
  • Accounting
  • Employment Law
3 minute read
  • SHARE ON

When a job requires employees to log more than 40 hours per week on a regular basis, is it safe to say overtime is an “essential job function” of that position and deny an accommodation request that attempts to skirt the OT?  

That question was at the heart of Agee v. Mercedes-Benz. The plaintiff, Kimberly Agee, had a disability — breast cancer — that required a lifting restriction saying she wasn’t allowed to lift anything over 15 pounds. The company accommodated her lifting restriction by transferring her to work stations where she wouldn’t have to lift anything over 15 pounds.

Then, Agee became pregnant and presented the company with a doctor’s note from her OB-GYN stating that she couldn’t work more than 40 hours per week “due to her medical limitations.”

When the company asked for additional information about the scheduling restriction, she returned with another note that reiterated the need for the 40-hour limit and lifting restrictions because of the pregnancy and her medical issues. However, this note also made it known that the hour-restriction was “seemingly indefinite.”

And here’s where things got interesting. Once company learned about the indefinite nature of the accommodation, it let Agee know it couldn’t accommodate a permanent 40-hour workweek restriction because working mandatory overtime was an essential function of the job. Instead, it told Agee she was being placed on unpaid FMLA leave and that she need to get the doctor to lift the restrictions or it would eventually terminate her.

Agee opted not to take leave, so the company twice restated (in writing) its position that it couldn’t accommodate the hours restriction and told her to fill out the FMLA paperwork.

Although Agee refused to fill out the paperwork, she told the company that she wasn’t abandoning her job. Because Agee never went on leave but wound up missing work. As a result, she racked up a series of unexcused absences and the company wound up firing her as a result of those absences.

Agee then filed an ADA disability discrimination suit against the company.

What the court said

The court agreed with the company’s argument that working overtime was an essential function of Agee’s position. Therefore, Agee wasn’t a qualified individual because the indefinite restriction on her hours ensured she wouldn’t be able to work overtime — an essential function of her position.

Bottom line: Agee couldn’t perform the essential functions of the job with or without the accommodation, so the company did not violate the ADA by refusing to grant her indefinite scheduling restriction and firing her for unexcused absences.

It helped the company’s case that both the job description for Agee’s position backed up the position that working OT was an essential job function and that it had offered her unpaid leave while the two sides tried to come to some type of arrangement.

3 best practices

The court’s ruling here confirms something very useful for employers regarding the handling of ADA accommodation requests: You can deny accommodations that would lime employees’ abilities to fulfill essential job functions — even if those functions are working mandatory overtime hours.

Of course, employers want to avoid situations that lead to the courtroom altogether. To that end, The Employer Handbook offers these three tips for handling accommodations:

  1. Review and update job descriptions regularly. In order to claim something is an essential job function, you should be able to show it was listed in the job description — like the company in this case did.
  2. Consider other options. Instead of focusing solely on whether an employee can perform a single job function, look for transfers to other positions or leave (just not indefinite leave) as a reasonable accommodation. And document the process. This show you tried to go above and beyond for the person.
  3. Be flexible. Communicate regularly and offer a number of different accommodation opportunities. Remember, the more accommodations an employee refuses, the more unreasonable he or she will appear about the process.

Keep Up To Date with the Latest Finance News

With CFO Daily News arriving in your inbox, you will never miss critical stories on accounting, benefits, payroll & employment law strategies.

Sign up for a free CFO Daily News membership and get our newsletter!
  • This field is for validation purposes and should be left unchanged.
CFO Daily News Logo
  • ABOUT CFO DAILY NEWS
  • ADVERTISE WITH US
  • WRITE FOR US
  • CONTACT
  • Accounting
  • Benefits
  • Payroll
  • Policy and Culture
  • Employment Law
  • Fraud
  • Finance Technology
  • Accounts Payable
  • Credit and Collections
  • Strategy
  • Payments and Transactions
  • Budgeting and Forecasting
  • Banking
  • Staff Management
  • Cost Control
  • Supply Chain
  • IT

CFO Daily News, part of the SuccessFuel Network, provides the latest Finance and employment law news for Finance professionals in the trenches of small-to-medium-sized businesses. Rather than simply regurgitating the day’s headlines, CFO Daily News delivers actionable insights, helping Finance execs understand what Finance trends mean to their business.

Privacy Policy Terms of Service
Copyright © 2021 SuccessFuel

WELCOME BACK!

Enter your username and password below to log in

Forget Your Username or Password?

Reset Password

Lost your password? Please enter your username or email address. You will receive a link to create a new password via email.

Log In

preloader